Sunday, November 9, 2008

Worried about appeasement? Try a martini with Mr. K.


A stirring moment in cold war history


As Barack Obama prepares for the big move to 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue, one of the nagging questions remains is: Has he drawn the proper historical lessons from John F. Kennedy’s meeting with Nikita S. Khrushchev in Vienna in June 1961? Well, that depends on whom you ask. On one side of the Danube are those who argue that the meeting was a bold gesture signaling a hopeful new chapter in the Cold War. Encamped on the other bank are the cynics who assess that the weekend in Wien offered an occasion for the pipefitter from Kalinovka to take a birch switch to young Jack’s backside. Then there’s the earthy assessment of KGB agent Georgiy Bolshakov, who served as a go-between in D.C. during the Cuban Missile Crisis: When you put your hand up a girl’s dress, you expect her to scream, you don’t expect her to blush.

With that in mind, let us recall that in foreign policy, as in much of life, the road to hell is often paved with good intentions. That, and the devil is in the details—and the lessons we learn in the moment might not be the same lessons that historians distill. For example, some months after the Soviets shot down the U-2 piloted by Francis Gary Powers, Eisenhower’s outgoing secretary of state astutely observed that the incident offered a useful moral: not to have accidents.

So let’s turn back the pages to Vienna in ’61. Recall that in the previous couple years Khrushchev has already visited the United States twice, met Marilyn Monroe and visited the set of the movie Can-Can, toured a model American house with Richard Nixon in Moscow and thumped his shoe at the U.N. But that was when Ike was president. The new Administration—which presided over the invasion of the Bay of Pigs in April ’61—offers some new possibilities. So, drawing on Khrushchev’s memoirs, once-secret KGB files and, where need be, fleshing things out a bit as we fictioneers occasionally do, let’s look a little more closely at what really transpired, and see what nuanced lessons we might glean from that weekend.


What can you offer?

Kennedy couldn’t go to Vienna empty-handed. He brought a toy ship as a present—a model of the USS Constitution. Khrushchev was deeply touched, particularly because his intelligence sources informed him that the ship was given to Kennedy by his own father. Kennedy spoke of revolution, of persistence, of the Founding Fathers’ fighting to establish a nation of free people.

“This is a good symbol of the time when the United States was the leader in the fight for freedom,” Khrushchev said. “As a matter of fact, the Russian tsar refused to recognize the United States for twenty-six years because he regarded it as an illegitimate creature.”

Kennedy shared a lesson on the functioning of American democracy. “Through the checks and balances of our system,” Kennedy said, “and through the power vested in the people, a government’s days would be numbered if it works only in the interest of a small group.”

Khrushchev patted Kennedy on the arm. “Tell me,” Khrushchev said, “has the Shah of Iran been let in on that secret?”



Think big

On Saturday, while Mrs. Khrushchev toured the Cezanne exhibition and Jackie inspected the state-of-the-art technology and the conditions for workers at a ball-bearing plant, the men met at the American ambassador’s residence, drank very dry martinis and agreed to go to the Moon together. Kennedy’s suggestion.

“Why not?” Khrushchev said.

They ate Beef Wellington and spoke of the elimination of nuclear missiles and bases, though Kennedy pooh-poohed that as the stuff of fairy tales. “On the other hand,” Kennedy said, “a nuclear test ban would be, if not the most important step, at least a significant step, toward disarmament. There is a Chinese proverb that says, A journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step.”

Khrushchev glared over the rim of his glass. Why quote the Chinese back to him? Trying to exploit the rift that Mao, that lunatic on a throne, has rent in world communism? “You seem to know the Chinese quite well,” Khrushchev said. “But I too know them quite well.”

“You might get to know them even better.”



Smoke ’em if you got ’em

They savored Cuban cigars. Khrushchev’s contribution. He understood that the Cuban revolution had already left a bad taste in the mouth of Amerika. But the tobacco is good.

“We should be perfectly clear,” Kennedy said, “that while Marxist ideology considers communist revolution as inevitable historically, the United States does not consider it inevitable and will, of necessity, oppose it.”

Khrushchev chuckled. He did not expect a lesson on the tenets of Marxism from a millionaire’s son. He blew three smoke rings and said, “Do I understand correctly? If communism moves into new areas, the U.S. will be in direct conflict with the Soviet Union? Dams cannot be placed in the way of the development of the human mind, Mr. President. Talk to your friend Sinatra about dams. He and I had a discussion about them when I was out in Hollywoodland. We remember from history, too, that the Spanish Inquisition burned people who disagreed with it, but ideas did not burn and eventually conquered.”

“All I’m saying,” Kennedy says, “is beware of any miscalculations that might lead to war.”

Khrushchev smiled and rested his palms on the table. “Does Amerika want the Soviet Union to sit like a schoolboy with hands on top of the desk? We don’t make mistakes. This is not a drill in mathematics or a quiz in grammar. Miscalculation!” He thumped the wood. “Tomorrow is Sunday. You will go to the cathedral. But tell me honestly: If I go to the cathedral to pray for peace, who will listen?” Boom! Khrushchev smacked the tabletop again. “Nobody,” he said. “Nobody will listen. But if I go with two bombs and say I want peace, they will listen.”


Find common ground

Beyond the trip to the Moon, there was something else everyone could agree on Saturday night: Jackie looked absolutely stunning, eyes and dress asparkle. And oh! what a dress: a sleeveless, floor-length Cassini, shell-pink silk-georgette chiffon embroidered with sequins. Jackie and Jack arrived fashionably late at Schönnbrünn Palace and stepped out of the limo, and the photographers coaxed Khrushchev toward Kennedy in his monkey suit—How about a shot of the two of you shaking hands? Khrushchev reached for the First Lady’s gloved fingers: “I’d rather shake her hand first!” Khrushchev sat beside her at dinner and regaled her with tales of the great economic and social progress they are making on all fronts, all across the Soviet Union. Take education. Far more teachers today than in 1917.

“Oh, Mr. Chairman,” she said, “don’t bore me with statistics.”

On Sunday the ladies brunched at Pallavicini Palace, guests of the Austrian president’s daughter. They stood on the balcony while giddy Viennese girls on the lawn and gravel drive below shrieked with glee, “Jah-kee! Jah-kee!” Gray-haired Nina Petrovna played the smiling babushka, kissed and hugged Jackie as if she were her own daughter.



Drink up

Sunday it was Khrushchev’s turn to play host. He welcomed Kennedy to the small piece of Soviet territory in Vienna and offered bread and salt and a libation to launch the Sunday morning negotiations, because a good beginning makes for a good finish. “Sometimes we drink out of a small glass,” Khrushchev said. “But we speak with great feelings.”

“I’m glad to hear that,” Kennedy said.

They feasted on gifts from the sea: red and black caviar on buttered bread, fish soup, sturgeon in aspic, and pastries stuffed with sweet, rich crabmeat harvested by Soviet slave labor. Kennedy acknowledged that the Sino-Soviet forces and those arrayed by the U.S. and Western Europe were more or less in balance. But as always, all roads led to Berlin.

“The absurdity of the situation is this,” said Khrushchev. “The U.S. doesn’t want Berlin. The U.S.S.R. doesn’t want Berlin. Only Adenauer wants it. He is a good man, but old. The old and moribund should not hold back the young and vigorous. We want a resolution. Our troops are not there to play cards, we mean business.”

“But Mr. Khrushchev,” Kennedy said, “why change the status quo now? Leave things the way they are—for another five years, say, after which everyone will be older and wiser, and perhaps then we can negotiate.”

Khrushchev drained a glass of mineral water, then set the glass very carefully on the table. “My decision to sign a peace treaty is final.”

“If that’s true,” Kennedy said, “it’s going to be a cold winter.” His voice was steady, but the man’s face was white with fear.



Sow the seeds

Certainly there were a couple of bumps ahead in the relationship between the two K’s. There was the unpleasantness over Berlin a few months later (the wall in August, the standoff with tanks in October) and the crisis in the Caribbean in ’62 (nuclear missiles and battlefield nukes sent to Cuba). But by the summer of ’63, JFK and NSK had signed a nuclear test ban treaty and Khrushchev was taking Secretary of State Dean Rusk waterskiing in the Black Sea. Despite vocal opposition to the treaty in the U.S., Kennedy told Khrushchev not to worry about loudmouths in the Senate. As usual, ten times as many Americans had written in asking the President for money than had shared opinions on foreign policy.

More important, once the American papers leaked the news that the little bitch Pushinka, which Khrushchev gave the Kennedys in Vienna, was now the proud mother of a litter of pupniks, thanks to a liaison with Caroline’s terrier, a torrent of new mail reached the White House: Tens of thousands of concerned citizens were writing to the President, offering to adopt.

As the Obamas choose their puppy, that’s something to keep in mind, too.

No comments: