Tuesday, October 12, 2010

Mr. K’s shoe – or – learning a lesson from a moment 50 years ago that never happened


October 13, 1960, the U.N. General Assembly. Nikita Khrushchev, leader of the fearsome Soviet empire at the rostrum. It’s a moment vividly etched in the memory of millions, thick with the atomic angst and absurdity of the Cold War. If you weren’t alive to witness it, you’ve seen the footage and the photos: Khrushchev pounds his shoe on the podium and he hollers, “We will bury you!”

Only it never happened. At least not quite like that. But that is how it is recalled in countless op eds and letters to the editor (or even in pieces by sloppy journalists) before being entered, most recently, as evidence to bolster a frightening historical narrative where the United States sells out its democratic ideals for a dose of meds: Obama was elected, sales of ammunition and Ayn Rand’s Atlas Shrugged skyrocketed, health insurance reform was passed, and the Commies buried us. Mr. K the shoe-banger was right.

There were and are lessons to be learned from Khrushchev’s antics and rhetoric. There are also important lessons to be learned from the broad blurring of historical memory toward political ends. Draw false lessons from an imagined past and where can that lead? This fall, it was Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad playing the self-appointed bombthrower at the General Assembly. He’s already denied the Holocaust ever happened; this year he regurgitated conspiracy theories about the attacks of Sept. 11, 2001 as being staged to bolster the U.S. economy and prop up “the Zionist regime.”

But saying doesn’t make it so. When Dwight Eisenhower hosted Nikita Khrushchev for a state dinner at the White House in 1959 (a year before the shoe business), Ike offered a toast where he said, in part: “We must depend upon truth and fact.” Amen. So—with that in mind, what about Mr. K, the shoe, and We will bury you? Let’s start with the burying.

“History is on our side.”
Khrushchev said it, all right—in Moscow, in December 1956, at a reception at the Polish embassy. It was a tough year for world communism: in February, Khrushchev gave his secret speech denouncing Stalin’s crimes; by summer there were riots in Poland where full-scale fighting was averted only after Soviet tanks were already rolling on Warsaw; that autumn in Hungary, hundreds of Soviet tanks crushed the revolution. But it was a tough year for democratically-elected governments, too—especially with the mess over the Suez Canal. French, British, and Israeli troops seized the waterway back from the Egyptians and tried to paint the intervention as a police action. Eisenhower didn’t buy it. Certainly Khrushchev didn’t; the mess stunk of colonial powers trying to reclaim the past.

With this as the context, Khrushchev’s line about burying came during a speech that was fierce but punctuated with moments of comic relief. “Don’t be stubborn if you see you are wrong,” he declared, “but don’t give in if you are right.”

“When are you right?” quipped his friend and fellow Politburo member Anastas Mikoyan. (Cue rim shot.)

In the speech, Khrushchev went on to defend Soviet actions in Hungary and berate the Brits and the French for aggression in Egypt. He told the diplomats from the West who were in attendance, “If you don't like us, don't accept our invitations, and don't invite us to come to see you. Whether you like it or not, history is on our side. We will bury you!”

The diplomats didn’t wait to see if he’d pull out a shovel. They walked out.

But invitations continued to be given, and accepted—including the one by Eisenhower to Khrushchev to visit the United States in 1959. When Khrushchev spoke to the National Press Club in Washington on that trip, one question put to him was what he meant by the burying line. First Khrushchev made a joke out of it; surveying the luncheon crowd assembled, the one-time miner said, “If I were to start to try to bury even this group, one life would not be enough.”

Then he explained that capitalism had replaced feudalism; communism is the next stage of development. But he conceded, if capitalism “is a better form of society and gives better opportunities to develop a country’s productive forces, then certainly it would win.” He also noted that, at the time, the Soviet Union was graduating three times as many engineers a year as the United States. (These days we still worry about the lack of engineers being graduated stateside—especially U.S.-born engineers—only it’s not the Soviets who are burying this country when we look at that statistic.)

But what about the shoe? Ah, well, it’s like this: Perhaps Khrushchev banged it. Perhaps he didn’t. There are conflicting reports by folks who were there at the time. One journalist for the New York Times saw Khrushchev bang the shoe, so he reported it that way; another Times reporter said he saw Khrushchev not bang the shoe. But the story was off and running. Historian William Taubman, the author of the biography Khrushchev: The Man and His Era, investigated multiple sources and came up with a definite maybe. Some who were there say Khrushchev waved the shoe, some say he banged the heel of his hand while holding the shoe. Khrushchev’s son Sergei and granddaughter Nina have tried to sort out the answer as well; what really happened remains unclear.

The memory of many folks to the contrary, there is no footage of Khrushchev banging the shoe. There is footage of him pounding his fists on the desktop while a delegate from the Philippines stands at the rostrum and laments how the Soviets gobbled up Eastern Europe. (Khrushchev, in turn, called the man from the Philippines a “lackey of Western imperialism.”) There is a photograph of a light brown sandal perched on the desk in front of Khrushchev. There is also the fact that things got so chaotic that day in the UN that the president of the General Assembly smacked his gavel hard enough to send the head of his mallet flying. (To be fair, the president was an Irishman, and the Romanian delegate to the UN had insulted the Irish.)

Fifty years later, when Iran’s Ahmadinejad was back at the UN giving his latest speech, there were no broken gavels or pounded shoes. Ahmadinejad predicted the end of capitalism. Diplomats walked out.

Meanwhile, this fall the clever photo-retouchers at Forbes magazine created a mock-historical image by putting President Obama on a bench next to Vladimir Lenin. What many folks missed in that particularly atrocious bit of pic-foolery: Steve Forbes’ Photoshoppers put Obama’s head on the body of Josef Stalin. It’s not clear whether the irony of the act of retouching itself—a hallmark of the Stalin era—was lost on the Forbes crew.

Just as forgetting the past brings its perils, playing fast and loose with history puts one in dangerous company. I lived a number of years in the former Soviet Union, and one of the Soviet-era phrases that folks like to recite, to help outsiders understand the nature of Soviet propaganda: “The future we know. It’s that past that’s uncertain.” Instead, let’s raise a glass with Ike: To truth and fact.